The Bermuda Triangle has long captured imaginations with tales of vanishing ships and strange phenomena, but scientists now suggest the real mystery lies far beneath the island itself. A new study in Geophysical Research Letters reveals a massive, previously unknown rock layer under Bermuda’s oceanic crust that may explain why the island has stayed above water for more than 30 million years, long after its volcanoes went dormant.
This discovery challenges previous assumptions about how islands sink over time and provides new insight into the forces shaping Earth’s crust.
Mapping the Ocean Floor
Seismologists William Frazer of Carnegie Science and Jeffrey Park of Yale University analyzed seismic waves from 396 distant earthquakes to map the rocks beneath Bermuda, reaching depths of about 31 miles. Their results revealed a 12.4-mile-thick layer of rock, far thicker than anything previously observed beneath similar islands.
“This layer is unlike anything we’ve ever seen,” said Frazer. “It seems to act like a raft, holding Bermuda high above the ocean floor despite millions of years of volcanic inactivity.”
The team’s findings highlight the complex geology of Bermuda, demonstrating that islands are shaped not only by volcanic activity but also by hidden structures deep beneath the surface.
How the Rock Layer Formed
While the exact origin remains unclear, researchers have proposed several possibilities:
- Stalled magma: Some molten rock may have cooled and solidified beneath the crust instead of erupting, forming a thick, buoyant pluton.
- Volatile-rich melts: Rising magma may have chemically altered the upper mantle, leaving lighter material that supports the island.
- Metasomatic underplating: Hot upwelling material could have cracked the crust, allowing seawater to seep in and partially transform the mantle.
These processes suggest that Bermuda’s survival is the result of both geological chance and complex subterranean dynamics.
Bermuda’s Unique Geological Position

Bermuda sits atop an oceanic swell, where the crust rises approximately 500 meters above the surrounding seafloor. Experts say this unusual positioning, combined with the massive underplate, explains why Bermuda has remained elevated, even after 31 million years of volcanic dormancy.
Geologist Sarah Mazza of Smith College emphasizes the island’s uniqueness: “Bermuda sits in a region that was once the heart of the last supercontinent. That history helps explain why this island’s geology is so extraordinary.”
Implications for Earth Science
Frazer and Park are now investigating whether other islands worldwide might harbor similar structures. Understanding Bermuda’s unusual underplate could help scientists differentiate between typical and extreme geological processes, offering insight into how islands can remain stable for tens of millions of years.
“Bermuda is an extreme case,” Frazer said. “Studying it allows us to understand both the normal and extraordinary forces at work beneath Earth’s surface.”
This discovery transforms Bermuda from merely a legendary Atlantic mystery into a scientific marvel, revealing hidden forces that have shaped the island for millions of years — and offering a new perspective on how Earth itself evolves over deep time.